Function for Fitting Spatial Factor Multi-Species Occupancy Models

The function sfMsPGOcc fits multi-species spatial occupancy models with species correlations (i.e., a spatially-explicit joint species distribution model with imperfect detection). We use Polya-Gamma latent variables and a spatial factor modeling approach. Currently, models are implemented using a Nearest Neighbor Gaussian Process.

Usage

sfMsPGOcc(occ.formula, det.formula, data, inits, priors, tuning, 
          cov.model = 'exponential', NNGP = TRUE, 
          n.neighbors = 15, search.type = 'cb', n.factors, n.batch, 
          batch.length, accept.rate = 0.43, n.omp.threads = 1, 
          verbose = TRUE, n.report = 100, 
          n.burn = round(.10 * n.batch * batch.length), n.thin = 1, 
          n.chains = 1, k.fold, k.fold.threads = 1, k.fold.seed, 
          k.fold.only = FALSE, ...)

Arguments

occ.formula: a symbolic description of the model to be fit for the occurrence portion of the model using R's model syntax. Random intercepts are allowed using lme4 syntax (Bates et al. 2015). Only right-hand side of formula is specified. See example below.
det.formula: a symbolic description of the model to be fit for the detection portion of the model using R's model syntax. Only right-hand side of formula is specified. See example below. Random intercepts are allowed using lme4 syntax (Bates et al. 2015).
data: a list containing data necessary for model fitting. Valid tags are y, occ.covs, det.covs, coords, and grid.index. y is a three-dimensional array with first dimension equal to the number of species, second dimension equal to the number of sites, and third dimension equal to the maximum number of replicates at a given site. occ.covs is a matrix or data frame containing the variables used in the occurrence portion of the model, with \(J\) rows for each column (variable). det.covs is a list of variables included in the detection portion of the model. Each list element is a different detection covariate, which can be site-level or observational-level. Site-level covariates are specified as a vector of length \(J\) while observation-level covariates are specified as a matrix or data frame with the number of rows equal to \(J\) and number of columns equal to the maximum number of replicates at a given site. coords is a matrix of the observation coordinates used to estimate the spatial random effect for each site. coords has two columns for the easting and northing coordinate, respectively. Typically, each site in the data set will have it's own coordinate, such that coords is a \(J \times 2\) matrix and grid.index should not be specified. If you desire to estimate spatial random effects at some larger spatial level, e.g., if points fall within grid cells and you want to estimate a spatial random effect for each grid cell instead of each point, coords can be specified as the coordinate for each grid cell. In such a case, grid.index is an indexing vector of length J, where each value of grid.index indicates the corresponding row in coords that the given site corresponds to. Note that spOccupancy assumes coordinates are specified in a projected coordinate system.
inits: a list with each tag corresponding to a parameter name. Valid tags are alpha.comm, beta.comm, beta, alpha, tau.sq.beta, tau.sq.alpha, sigma.sq.psi, sigma.sq.p, z, phi, lambda, and nu. nu is only specified if cov.model = "matern", and sigma.sq.psi and sigma.sq.p are only specified if random effects are included in occ.formula or det.formula, respectively. The value portion of each tag is the parameter's initial value. See priors description for definition of each parameter name. Additionally, the tag fix can be set to TRUE to fix the starting values across all chains. If fix is not specified (the default), starting values are varied randomly across chains.
priors: a list with each tag corresponding to a parameter name. Valid tags are beta.comm.normal, alpha.comm.normal, tau.sq.beta.ig, tau.sq.alpha.ig, tau.beta.half.t, tau.alpha.half.t, sigma.sq.psi, sigma.sq.p, phi.unif, and nu.unif. Community-level occurrence (beta.comm) and detection (alpha.comm) regression coefficients are assumed to follow a normal distribution. The hyperparameters of the normal distribution are passed as a list of length two with the first and second elements corresponding to the mean and variance of the normal distribution, which are each specified as vectors of length equal to the number of coefficients to be estimated or of length one if priors are the same for all coefficients. If not specified, prior means are set to 0 and prior variances set to 2.73. By default, community-level variance parameters for occupancy (tau.sq.beta) and detection (tau.sq.alpha) are assumed to follow an inverse Gamma distribution. The hyperparameters of the inverse gamma distribution are passed as a list of length two with the first and second elements corresponding to the shape and scale parameters, which are each specified as vectors of length equal to the number of coefficients to be estimated or a single value if priors are the same for all parameters. If not specified, prior shape and scale parameters are set to 0.1. Alternatively, half-t priors can be specified for the community level occurrence/detection standard deviation parameters using the tags tau.beta.half.t and tau.alpha.half.t. The hyperparameters of the half-t distribution are passed as a list of length two with the first and second elements corresponding to the degrees of freedom and scale parameters, which are each specified as vectors of length equal to the number of coefficients to be estimated or a single value if priors are the same for all parameters. The spatial factor model fits n.factors independent spatial processes. The spatial decay phi and smoothness nu parameters for each latent factor are assumed to follow Uniform distributions. The hyperparameters of the Uniform are passed as a list with two elements, with both elements being vectors of length n.factors corresponding to the lower and upper support, respectively, or as a single value if the same value is assigned for all factors. The priors for the factor loadings matrix lambda are fixed following the standard spatial factor model to ensure parameter identifiability (Christensen and Amemlya 2002). The upper triangular elements of the N x n.factors matrix are fixed at 0 and the diagonal elements are fixed at 1. The lower triangular elements are assigned a standard normal prior (i.e., mean 0 and variance 1). sigma.sq.psi and sigma.sq.p are the random effect variances for any occurrence or detection random effects, respectively, and are assumed to follow an inverse Gamma distribution. The hyperparameters of the inverse-Gamma distribution are passed as a list of length two with first and second elements corresponding to the shape and scale parameters, respectively, which are each specified as vectors of length equal to the number of random intercepts or of length one if priors are the same for all random effect variances.
tuning: a list with each tag corresponding to a parameter name. Valid tags are phi and nu. The value portion of each tag defines the initial variance of the adaptive sampler. We assume the initial variance of the adaptive sampler is the same for each species, although the adaptive sampler will adjust the tuning variances separately for each species. See Roberts and Rosenthal (2009) for details.
cov.model: a quoted keyword that specifies the covariance function used to model the spatial dependence structure among the observations. Supported covariance model key words are: "exponential", "matern", "spherical", and "gaussian".
NNGP: if TRUE, model is fit with an NNGP. If FALSE, a full Gaussian process is used. See Datta et al. (2016) and Finley et al. (2019) for more information. For spatial factor models, only NNGP = TRUE is currently supported.
n.neighbors: number of neighbors used in the NNGP. Only used if NNGP = TRUE. Datta et al. (2016) showed that 15 neighbors is usually sufficient, but that as few as 5 neighbors can be adequate for certain data sets, which can lead to even greater decreases in run time. We recommend starting with 15 neighbors (the default) and if additional gains in computation time are desired, subsequently compare the results with a smaller number of neighbors using WAIC or k-fold cross-validation.
search.type: a quoted keyword that specifies the type of nearest neighbor search algorithm. Supported method key words are: "cb" and "brute". The "cb" should generally be much faster. If locations do not have identical coordinate values on the axis used for the nearest neighbor ordering then "cb" and "brute" should produce identical neighbor sets. However, if there are identical coordinate values on the axis used for nearest neighbor ordering, then "cb" and "brute" might produce different, but equally valid, neighbor sets, e.g., if data are on a grid.
n.factors: the number of factors to use in the spatial factor model approach. Typically, the number of factors is set to be small (e.g., 4-5) relative to the total number of species in the community, which will lead to substantial decreases in computation time. However, the value can be anywhere between 1 and N (the number of species in the community).
n.batch: the number of MCMC batches in each chain to run for the Adaptive MCMC sampler. See Roberts and Rosenthal (2009) for details.
batch.length: the length of each MCMC batch to run for the Adaptive MCMC sampler. See Roberts and Rosenthal (2009) for details.
accept.rate: target acceptance rate for Adaptive MCMC. Defaul is 0.43. See Roberts and Rosenthal (2009) for details.
n.omp.threads: a positive integer indicating the number of threads to use for SMP parallel processing. The package must be compiled for OpenMP support. For most Intel-based machines, we recommend setting n.omp.threads up to the number of hyperthreaded cores. Note, n.omp.threads > 1 might not work on some systems.
verbose: if TRUE, messages about data preparation, model specification, and progress of the sampler are printed to the screen. Otherwise, no messages are printed.
n.report: the interval to report Metropolis sampler acceptance and MCMC progress. Note this is specified in terms of batches and not overall samples for spatial models.
n.burn: the number of samples out of the total n.samples to discard as burn-in for each chain. By default, the first 10% of samples is discarded.
n.thin: the thinning interval for collection of MCMC samples. The thinning occurs after the n.burn samples are discarded. Default value is set to 1.
n.chains: the number of chains to run in sequence.
k.fold: specifies the number of k folds for cross-validation. If not specified as an argument, then cross-validation is not performed and k.fold.threads and k.fold.seed are ignored. In k-fold cross-validation, the data specified in data is randomly partitioned into k equal sized subsamples. Of the k subsamples, k - 1 subsamples are used to fit the model and the remaining k samples are used for prediction. The cross-validation process is repeated k times (the folds). As a scoring rule, we use the model deviance as described in Hooten and Hobbs (2015). Cross-validation is performed after the full model is fit using all the data. Cross-validation results are reported in the k.fold.deviance object in the return list.
k.fold.threads: number of threads to use for cross-validation. If k.fold.threads > 1 parallel processing is accomplished using the foreach and doParallel packages. Ignored if k.fold is not specified.
k.fold.seed: seed used to split data set into k.fold parts for k-fold cross-validation. Ignored if k.fold is not specified.
k.fold.only: a logical value indicating whether to only perform cross-validation (TRUE) or perform cross-validation after fitting the full model (FALSE). Default value is FALSE.
...: currently no additional arguments

Note

Some of the underlying code used for generating random numbers from the Polya-Gamma distribution is taken from the pgdraw package written by Daniel F. Schmidt and Enes Makalic. Their code implements Algorithm 6 in PhD thesis of Jesse Bennett Windle (2013) https://repositories.lib.utexas.edu/handle/2152/21842.

References

Datta, A., S. Banerjee, A.O. Finley, and A.E. Gelfand. (2016) Hierarchical Nearest-Neighbor Gaussian process models for large geostatistical datasets. Journal of the American Statistical Association, doi:10.1080/01621459.2015.1044091 .

Finley, A.O., A. Datta, B.D. Cook, D.C. Morton, H.E. Andersen, and S. Banerjee. (2019) Efficient algorithms for Bayesian Nearest Neighbor Gaussian Processes. Journal of Computational and Graphical Statistics, doi:10.1080/10618600.2018.1537924 .

Finley, A. O., Datta, A., and Banerjee, S. (2020). spNNGP R package for nearest neighbor Gaussian process models. arXiv preprint arXiv:2001.09111.

Polson, N.G., J.G. Scott, and J. Windle. (2013) Bayesian Inference for Logistic Models Using Polya-Gamma Latent Variables. Journal of the American Statistical Association, 108:1339-1349.

Roberts, G.O. and Rosenthal J.S. (2009) Examples of adaptive MCMC. Journal of Computational and Graphical Statistics, 18(2):349-367.

Bates, Douglas, Martin Maechler, Ben Bolker, Steve Walker (2015). Fitting Linear Mixed-Effects Models Using lme4. Journal of Statistical Software, 67(1), 1-48. doi:10.18637/jss.v067.i01 .

Hooten, M. B., and Hobbs, N. T. (2015). A guide to Bayesian model selection for ecologists. Ecological Monographs, 85(1), 3-28.

Christensen, W. F., and Amemiya, Y. (2002). Latent variable analysis of multivariate spatial data. Journal of the American Statistical Association, 97(457), 302-317.

Author

Jeffrey W. Doser doserjef@msu.edu,
Andrew O. Finley finleya@msu.edu

Value

An object of class sfMsPGOcc that is a list comprised of:

beta.comm.samples: a coda object of posterior samples for the community level occurrence regression coefficients.
alpha.comm.samples: a coda object of posterior samples for the community level detection regression coefficients.
tau.sq.beta.samples: a coda object of posterior samples for the occurrence community variance parameters.
tau.sq.alpha.samples: a coda object of posterior samples for the detection community variance parameters.
beta.samples: a coda object of posterior samples for the species level occurrence regression coefficients.
alpha.samples: a coda object of posterior samples for the species level detection regression coefficients.
theta.samples: a coda object of posterior samples for the species level correlation parameters.
lambda.samples: a coda object of posterior samples for the latent spatial factor loadings.
z.samples: a three-dimensional array of posterior samples for the latent occurrence values for each species.
psi.samples: a three-dimensional array of posterior samples for the latent occupancy probability values for each species.
w.samples: a three-dimensional array of posterior samples for the latent spatial random effects for each latent factor.
sigma.sq.psi.samples: a coda object of posterior samples for variances of random intercepts included in the occurrence portion of the model. Only included if random intercepts are specified in occ.formula.
sigma.sq.p.samples: a coda object of posterior samples for variances of random intercpets included in the detection portion of the model. Only included if random intercepts are specified in det.formula.
beta.star.samples: a coda object of posterior samples for the occurrence random effects. Only included if random intercepts are specified in occ.formula.
alpha.star.samples: a coda object of posterior samples for the detection random effects. Only included if random intercepts are specified in det.formula.
like.samples: a three-dimensional array of posterior samples for the likelihood value associated with each site and species. Used for calculating WAIC.
rhat: a list of Gelman-Rubin diagnostic values for some of the model parameters.
ESS: a list of effective sample sizes for some of the model parameters.
run.time: MCMC sampler execution time reported using proc.time().
k.fold.deviance: vector of scoring rules (deviance) from k-fold cross-validation. A separate value is reported for each species. Only included if k.fold is specified in function call.

The return object will include additional objects used for subsequent prediction and/or model fit evaluation. Note that detection probability estimated values are not included in the model object, but can be extracted using fitted().

Examples

set.seed(400)

# Simulate Data -----------------------------------------------------------
J.x <- 7
J.y <- 7
J <- J.x * J.y
n.rep <- sample(2:4, size = J, replace = TRUE)
N <- 8
# Community-level covariate effects
# Occurrence
beta.mean <- c(0.2, -0.15)
p.occ <- length(beta.mean)
tau.sq.beta <- c(0.6, 0.3)
# Detection
alpha.mean <- c(0.5, 0.2, -.2)
tau.sq.alpha <- c(0.2, 0.3, 0.8)
p.det <- length(alpha.mean)
# Random effects
psi.RE <- list()
# Include a non-spatial random effect on occurrence
psi.RE <- list(levels = c(20),
               sigma.sq.psi = c(0.5))
p.RE <- list()
# Include a random effect on detection
p.RE <- list(levels = c(40),
       sigma.sq.p = c(2))
# Draw species-level effects from community means.
beta <- matrix(NA, nrow = N, ncol = p.occ)
alpha <- matrix(NA, nrow = N, ncol = p.det)
for (i in 1:p.occ) {
  beta[, i] <- rnorm(N, beta.mean[i], sqrt(tau.sq.beta[i]))
}
for (i in 1:p.det) {
  alpha[, i] <- rnorm(N, alpha.mean[i], sqrt(tau.sq.alpha[i]))
}
n.factors <- 4
phi <- runif(n.factors, 3/1, 3/.4)

dat <- simMsOcc(J.x = J.x, J.y = J.y, n.rep = n.rep, N = N, beta = beta, alpha = alpha,
                phi = phi, sp = TRUE, cov.model = 'exponential', 
                factor.model = TRUE, n.factors = n.factors, psi.RE = psi.RE, 
                p.RE = p.RE)

# Number of batches
n.batch <- 10
# Batch length
batch.length <- 25
n.samples <- n.batch * batch.length

y <- dat$y
X <- dat$X
X.p <- dat$X.p
X.p.re <- dat$X.p.re
X.re <- dat$X.re
coords <- as.matrix(dat$coords)

# Package all data into a list
occ.covs <- cbind(X, X.re)
colnames(occ.covs) <- c('int', 'occ.cov', 'occ.re')
det.covs <- list(det.cov.1 = X.p[, , 2], 
                 det.cov.2 = X.p[, , 3], 
                 det.re = X.p.re[, , 1])
data.list <- list(y = y, 
                  occ.covs = occ.covs,
                  det.covs = det.covs, 
                  coords = coords)
# Priors
prior.list <- list(beta.comm.normal = list(mean = 0, var = 2.72), 
                   alpha.comm.normal = list(mean = 0, var = 2.72), 
                   tau.sq.beta.ig = list(a = 0.1, b = 0.1), 
                   tau.sq.alpha.ig = list(a = 0.1, b = 0.1),
                   phi.unif = list(a = 3/1, b = 3/.1)) 
# Initial values
lambda.inits <- matrix(0, N, n.factors)
diag(lambda.inits) <- 1
lambda.inits[lower.tri(lambda.inits)] <- rnorm(sum(lower.tri(lambda.inits)))

inits.list <- list(alpha.comm = 0, 
                   beta.comm = 0, 
                   beta = 0, 
                   alpha = 0,
                   tau.sq.beta = 1, 
                   tau.sq.alpha = 1, 
                   phi = 3 / .5, 
                   lambda = lambda.inits,
                   z = apply(y, c(1, 2), max, na.rm = TRUE))
# Tuning
tuning.list <- list(phi = 1) 

out <- sfMsPGOcc(occ.formula = ~ occ.cov + (1 | occ.re), 
                 det.formula = ~ det.cov.1 + det.cov.2 + (1 | det.re), 
                 data = data.list,
                 inits = inits.list, 
                 n.batch = n.batch, 
                 batch.length = batch.length, 
                 accept.rate = 0.43, 
                 priors = prior.list, 
                 cov.model = "exponential", 
                 tuning = tuning.list, 
                 n.omp.threads = 1, 
                 verbose = TRUE, 
                 NNGP = TRUE, 
                 n.neighbors = 5, 
                 n.factors = n.factors,
                 search.type = 'cb', 
                 n.report = 10, 
                 n.burn = 50, 
                 n.thin = 1, 
                 n.chains = 1)
#> ----------------------------------------
#> 	Preparing to run the model
#> ----------------------------------------
#> No prior specified for sigma.sq.psi.ig.
#> Setting prior shape to 0.1 and prior scale to 0.1
#> No prior specified for sigma.sq.p.ig.
#> Setting prior shape to 0.1 and prior scale to 0.1
#> sigma.sq.psi is not specified in initial values.
#> Setting initial values to random values between 0.5 and 10
#> sigma.sq.p is not specified in initial values.
#> Setting initial values to random values between 0.5 and 10
#> ----------------------------------------
#> 	Building the neighbor list
#> ----------------------------------------
#> ----------------------------------------
#> Building the neighbors of neighbors list
#> ----------------------------------------
#> ----------------------------------------
#> 	Model description
#> ----------------------------------------
#> Spatial Factor NNGP Multi-species Occupancy Model with Polya-Gamma latent
#> variable fit with 49 sites and 8 species.
#> 
#> Samples per chain: 250 (10 batches of length 25)
#> Burn-in: 50 
#> Thinning Rate: 1 
#> Number of Chains: 1 
#> Total Posterior Samples: 200 
#> 
#> Using the exponential spatial correlation model.
#> 
#> Using 4 latent spatial factors.
#> Using 5 nearest neighbors.
#> 
#> Source compiled with OpenMP support and model fit using 1 thread(s).
#> 
#> Adaptive Metropolis with target acceptance rate: 43.0
#> ----------------------------------------
#> 	Chain 1
#> ----------------------------------------
#> Sampling ... 
#> Batch: 10 of 10, 100.00%

summary(out)
#> 
#> Call:
#> sfMsPGOcc(occ.formula = ~occ.cov + (1 | occ.re), det.formula = ~det.cov.1 + 
#>     det.cov.2 + (1 | det.re), data = data.list, inits = inits.list, 
#>     priors = prior.list, tuning = tuning.list, cov.model = "exponential", 
#>     NNGP = TRUE, n.neighbors = 5, search.type = "cb", n.factors = n.factors, 
#>     n.batch = n.batch, batch.length = batch.length, accept.rate = 0.43, 
#>     n.omp.threads = 1, verbose = TRUE, n.report = 10, n.burn = 50, 
#>     n.thin = 1, n.chains = 1)
#> 
#> Samples per Chain: 250
#> Burn-in: 50
#> Thinning Rate: 1
#> Number of Chains: 1
#> Total Posterior Samples: 200
#> Run Time (min): 0.0075
#> 
#> ----------------------------------------
#> 	Community Level
#> ----------------------------------------
#> Occurrence Means (logit scale): 
#>               Mean     SD    2.5%    50%  97.5% Rhat ESS
#> (Intercept) 0.0385 0.3073 -0.5165 0.0152 0.6213   NA  48
#> occ.cov     0.2679 0.2566 -0.3024 0.2652 0.7265   NA  53
#> 
#> Occurrence Variances (logit scale): 
#>               Mean     SD   2.5%    50%  97.5% Rhat ESS
#> (Intercept) 0.4044 0.4540 0.0519 0.2426 1.7275   NA  21
#> occ.cov     0.2339 0.2273 0.0338 0.1521 0.7879   NA  89
#> 
#> Occurrence Random Effect Variances (logit scale): 
#>          Mean     SD   2.5%    50%  97.5% Rhat ESS
#> occ.re 1.3693 0.6525 0.3828 1.3024 2.8738   NA   7
#> 
#> Detection Means (logit scale): 
#>                Mean     SD    2.5%     50%  97.5% Rhat ESS
#> (Intercept)  0.2862 0.2361 -0.1209  0.2576 0.8377   NA  72
#> det.cov.1    0.1017 0.1591 -0.2072  0.1032 0.3776   NA  67
#> det.cov.2   -0.4501 0.3806 -1.1544 -0.4277 0.1804   NA 200
#> 
#> Detection Variances (logit scale): 
#>               Mean     SD   2.5%    50%  97.5% Rhat ESS
#> (Intercept) 0.2489 0.1713 0.0438 0.2112 0.6769   NA  55
#> det.cov.1   0.1120 0.1263 0.0254 0.0802 0.4158   NA 104
#> det.cov.2   1.2651 0.9774 0.3136 1.0087 3.2655   NA 137
#> 
#> Detection Random Effect Variances (logit scale): 
#>          Mean     SD   2.5%    50% 97.5% Rhat ESS
#> det.re 1.7316 1.0879 0.5942 1.3272 4.571   NA   4
#> 
#> ----------------------------------------
#> 	Species Level
#> ----------------------------------------
#> Occurrence (logit scale): 
#>                    Mean     SD    2.5%     50%  97.5% Rhat ESS
#> (Intercept)-sp1  0.3913 0.4375 -0.3730  0.3541 1.2219   NA  48
#> (Intercept)-sp2  0.0220 0.4143 -0.8642  0.0172 0.8956   NA  28
#> (Intercept)-sp3 -0.1786 0.4445 -1.1206 -0.1192 0.5319   NA  45
#> (Intercept)-sp4  0.3570 0.5340 -0.7928  0.3281 1.4820   NA  40
#> (Intercept)-sp5 -0.1876 0.4540 -1.2134 -0.1588 0.6985   NA  21
#> (Intercept)-sp6 -0.3369 0.4706 -1.3205 -0.3569 0.5122   NA  30
#> (Intercept)-sp7  0.2136 0.5515 -0.6726  0.1124 1.4637   NA  22
#> (Intercept)-sp8  0.1679 0.4326 -0.5951  0.1559 1.0245   NA  53
#> occ.cov-sp1      0.5476 0.3410 -0.0500  0.5235 1.2996   NA  61
#> occ.cov-sp2      0.0289 0.3298 -0.6619  0.0477 0.6239   NA  33
#> occ.cov-sp3      0.4084 0.3543 -0.2872  0.3825 1.1448   NA  57
#> occ.cov-sp4      0.4117 0.3466 -0.2578  0.4236 1.0977   NA  54
#> occ.cov-sp5      0.2675 0.3630 -0.4765  0.2552 0.9581   NA 123
#> occ.cov-sp6      0.0703 0.3656 -0.6008  0.0553 0.8405   NA  57
#> occ.cov-sp7      0.1964 0.3365 -0.5307  0.2243 0.7586   NA  64
#> occ.cov-sp8      0.3723 0.3601 -0.3409  0.3706 1.0215   NA  76
#> 
#> Detection (logit scale): 
#>                    Mean     SD    2.5%     50%   97.5% Rhat ESS
#> (Intercept)-sp1 -0.0611 0.2920 -0.5407 -0.0870  0.5454   NA  91
#> (Intercept)-sp2  0.5753 0.3785 -0.0543  0.5220  1.3590   NA  41
#> (Intercept)-sp3  0.2926 0.2874 -0.3318  0.3306  0.8662   NA  75
#> (Intercept)-sp4  0.0537 0.3690 -0.6649  0.0055  0.8910   NA  38
#> (Intercept)-sp5  0.7003 0.3735  0.1261  0.6475  1.4728   NA  52
#> (Intercept)-sp6  0.3347 0.3851 -0.3462  0.3038  1.1967   NA  62
#> (Intercept)-sp7  0.0617 0.2984 -0.5632  0.0913  0.5726   NA  70
#> (Intercept)-sp8  0.4513 0.2792 -0.1081  0.4525  0.9825   NA  60
#> det.cov.1-sp1    0.2066 0.2326 -0.2241  0.2013  0.7156   NA  76
#> det.cov.1-sp2    0.0084 0.2183 -0.4374  0.0100  0.4501   NA 115
#> det.cov.1-sp3    0.0306 0.2623 -0.4912  0.0707  0.4460   NA  96
#> det.cov.1-sp4    0.1537 0.2300 -0.2530  0.1497  0.5539   NA 101
#> det.cov.1-sp5    0.0087 0.2494 -0.4818  0.0159  0.4481   NA  69
#> det.cov.1-sp6    0.2103 0.3121 -0.2864  0.1912  0.8277   NA  60
#> det.cov.1-sp7    0.1963 0.2176 -0.2116  0.1887  0.6483   NA 107
#> det.cov.1-sp8    0.0800 0.2477 -0.4265  0.0803  0.5299   NA  86
#> det.cov.2-sp1   -0.1586 0.2996 -0.7568 -0.1381  0.3774   NA 102
#> det.cov.2-sp2   -1.5033 0.4299 -2.3823 -1.4738 -0.7980   NA  78
#> det.cov.2-sp3    0.2406 0.3734 -0.3820  0.2200  1.1464   NA  87
#> det.cov.2-sp4   -0.7081 0.2983 -1.3764 -0.6810 -0.1276   NA 102
#> det.cov.2-sp5    0.2268 0.3891 -0.5124  0.1827  1.0351   NA  74
#> det.cov.2-sp6    0.6858 0.4444 -0.0575  0.6544  1.5303   NA  73
#> det.cov.2-sp7   -1.9245 0.3793 -2.7200 -1.9310 -1.2733   NA  54
#> det.cov.2-sp8   -0.5498 0.3476 -1.2414 -0.5152  0.1081   NA  84
#> 
#> ----------------------------------------
#> 	Spatial Covariance
#> ----------------------------------------
#>          Mean     SD   2.5%     50%   97.5% Rhat ESS
#> phi-1 15.9673 6.7291 5.6948 14.8528 28.4101   NA  14
#> phi-2 15.2604 8.8463 3.2689 16.3848 28.6129   NA   3
#> phi-3 14.4463 9.1038 3.1108 13.3008 29.4251   NA   5
#> phi-4 18.7865 6.5013 7.0897 19.7372 28.4726   NA  22